Before: Alexandria and others arrive to get court-awarded property. Jacob told Alexandria not to bring Eric.
Argument: Jacob and Eric argue. Eric slaps phone. Jacob tackles Eric onto car hood. Others intervene.
Break-up: Fight breaks up. Eric retreats to truck. Jacob draws gun, shoves Alexandria, points gun, shoots Eric.
Aftermath: Eric shot in abdomen. Group leaves. Jacob arrested. Videos and evidence seized.
| Point | Defense Claim (Jacob) | Witness Version |
|---|---|---|
| Initiation | Jacob says he was attacked, feared for life. | Witnesses say Jacob started by tackling Eric. |
| Fight ending | Jacob says threat remained. | All say fight was over; Eric retreating. |
| Gun use | Self-defense, imminent threat. | Witnesses: Jacob advanced, pointed gun, shot as others backed off. |
Under Michigan law, Stand Your Ground does not protect an aggressor or someone who continues force after threat ends.